What would Chinese people think of America torturing Bradley Manning?

Question

What would Chinese people think of America torturing Bradley Manning :

"The inhumane conditions of Bradley Manning's detention"
http://www.salon.com/news/opinion/glenn_greenwald/2010/12/14/manning/index.html

The west media refuses to report on this, but you can Google it:
http://www.google.ca/#hl=en&biw=1184&bih=534&q=manning%20torture&um=1&ie=UTF-8&sa=N&tab=nw&fp=1&cad=b

What would Chinese people think of America torturing Bradley Manning ?

Answer 1

Hello WNL Clone#4 copying my avatar, but with a more appropriate name for yourself.

Are you still lacking in originality and integrity?



I suppose the Chinese are as amused by this poor effort to copy their tried-and-true torture methods as the Americans are at the CCP's poor effort to be a respectable country.



Now, can you offer any questions related to travel in China? Or, are you simply an instigator of trouble, posing as CCP propagandist, and masquerading behind an emblem you don't understand?

Answer 2

None of the Chinese people I know ever heard of Bradley Manning, nor do they care about his level of treatment. When I explained more about what he did, two mentioned that if he had done the same thing in China he'd probably have been executed by now for treason against the State. Another said that this American's living conditions sound pretty good, compared to the city jail his cousin is in (for minor theft).



Regarding your tirade against "Reporter" -- what are you smoking or snorting? I see he's asked one question - about getting a tourist visa. And he has answered questions on topics like does the Concord still fly to France, what's a reasonable layover time at O'Hare and some obscure antique radio. Nowhere does he say anything that could be construed as "political" except by someone who is delusional.



Meanwhile, you bring up a social issue that really has nothing to do with the country or culture of China except for the fact you use the word "Chinese" as part of your question. That's as facetious as asking "Do the Chinese think that the Chicago Cubs will win the World Series next year?"



Pot calling the kettle black?

Answer 3

That is not torture. Solitary confinement is to be anticipated on this type of case. PFC Manning has now not precisely been cooperative with the research. If he wasn't in solitary, how would his protection be assured. There are plenty of folks within the army that maybe inclined to recreation a few additional-judicial punishment for what he has been accused of, and that's not reasonable to anybody. As a ways as now not having blankets or pillows, he has threatened suicide, so whatever that he would probably use to harm himself could were taken away. The man merits his day in court docket, and the army is obligated to peer that he will get it.

Answer 4

the Chinese laugh at American torturing

the Chinese think Americans doesn't know how to torture

Chinese think Americans should come and look at how the Chinese Communist Party does it, about torturing Falun Gong and other prisoners.





on another note, CCP is so very careful not to hurt Liu Xiaobo. Any injury on Liu Xiaobo will be perceived as CCP torturing the Nobel Prize winner. The rumor is the prison guards so very carefully watch his every step so he won't trip or fall down the stair. The CCP can only hope some natural phenomenon like lighting strikes or earthquake killing Liu Xiaobo.

Answer 5

nothings new.........the whole world already knows that the democracy in the west is nothing but whole bunch of sneaky cunning hypocrites whose actual deeds are 00000000000s times worst than their so called moral high grounds.......the dozens yahoo accounts on here that is only played by the 1 or 2 max. CIA payroll tells it all.......pathetic to earn his wages by repeating day-nite rubbish on here..............

Answer 6

I would think many Chinese people in jail would be jealous of his conditions. While its possible to find a lawyer with a point of view of that living in a room like this, like the one shown in your link, is torture many Chinese prisoners undergo real torture for false confessions. Like Zhao Zuohai and She Xianglin who confessed to murder under torture and then release once the murder victim was found alive, as shown in this link.



http://www.chinadaily.com.cn/usa/2010-12/07/content_11663849.htm

Answer 7

This is the TRAVEL section. Take your politically motivated propaganda elsewhere



Reported



EDIT



I stand by what I said. Take your politically motivated opinion elsewhere . It's not welcome on Y!A



EDIT I'm not in the USA and have no allegiance to the USA but I object to Y!A being used to propagate propaganda whatever the source.